12 shows like The Fall of El Mayo

Looking for shows like The Fall of El Mayo (2026)? Here are 12 similar shows — including Trust Me: The False Prophet, Conversations with a Killer: The Jeffrey Dahmer Tapes and The Idaho Murders: College Nightmare. Add any of them to your PlayQueue backlog in one tap.

Browse more shows

Track what to play, watch & read next

One backlog for games, movies & TV, with AI-curated picks for what to start next — free for up to 50 items.

Create your free account